Valuation
Methodology Overview
Accounting book value
seldom, if ever, reflects the market value of a business
because most businesses sell based upon their earnings or
cash flow. Asset value, or more appropriately, net asset
value, may provide a lower limit on value for holding
companies or in cases where earnings are low.
Excess earnings, or
earnings above those required on the investment in working
capital and fixed assets, give rise to goodwill or
intangible value. The difference between accounting book
value and market value is best illustrated in the diagram
below.
The value of owner's equity
can be estimated through various methodologies including:
discounted cash flow, comparable company, comparable
transaction and adjusted net worth. The use of a market
multiple based upon transactions of comparable companies can
be used to estimate the value of a business.
Value can be estimated by
applying the market multiple to the subject company's
earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and
amortization charges. Establishing a recurring earning
estimate (EBITDA) is the key to arrive at a meaningful value
estimate.
The recurring earnings base
may require an adjustment to officer/owner compensation and
removal of all one time or extraordinary expenses. In
addition, any investment income should be removed to reflect
only earnings attributable to operations.
The recurring earnings base
can then be capitalized by use of a market multiple. Adding
the value of non-operating assets such as excess cash,
marketable securities, and other assets held for investment
produces an estimate of enterprise value. Value estimates
of minority interests require discounts for lack of control
and lack of marketability.
This methodology as steps:
1) Calculate an annual
recurring earnings base.
a) Remove all non-operating income and
expenses.
b) Adjust owner/officer compensation to market
rates.
c) Remove all one time or non-recurring income
or expense.
2) Add back all interest,
income tax, and non-cash expenses such as depreciation,
amortization
and depletion expenses to arrive at EBITDA.
3) Apply a market EBITDA
multiple and add non-operating assets to arrive at
enterprise value.
4) Subtract interest-bearing
debt from enterprise value to obtain a marketable equity
value indication.
5) For minority interests,
apply discounts for lack of control and lack of
marketability to pro-rata control
value.
This calculation provides
useful information for most businesses. However, it may not
be appropriate for holding companies or companies with low
or negative earnings.